What a Good Month Looks Like: Benchmarks for a Local Practice
Every month, practice owners ask us some version of the same question: was that a good month? Not in revenue terms. They know their revenue. They mean the marketing. Did the ads work? Is the website pulling its weight? Are we getting enough new people in the door, or does it just feel busy? Without marketing benchmarks for a local practice, you're grading yourself on vibes.
So here's the honest version. These are the numbers we look at when we decide whether a month was good, okay, or a problem. They're ranges, not promises, and your market will move them. But if you're way outside these lines, it's worth asking why.
First, the one number that matters most
New patients or customers who actually showed up. Not leads. Not clicks. Not followers. People who walked in, sat in the chair, and became a real relationship. Every other benchmark below exists to explain that number.
A good month is one where that number is steady or climbing, and you can explain where those people came from. If you can't answer the second part, fix your tracking before you touch anything else. Add a how did you hear about us question to intake, make sure calls from your ads and website are tracked, and actually read the answers.
Lead volume: are enough people raising their hand?
A lead is a phone call, a form fill, a booking request, or a message from someone who wants to come in. For most small local practices we work with, a healthy month of paid and organic marketing produces somewhere in the range of 30 to 80 real leads. Smaller markets and narrow specialties sit at the low end. Busy multi-provider offices sit higher.
What matters more than the raw count is the trend and the quality. Twenty great leads beats sixty people asking if you're open Sunday. Read your form submissions and listen to a few call recordings every month. You'll learn more in twenty minutes than any dashboard will tell you.
Cost per lead: what's normal?
Cost per lead is your ad spend divided by the leads it produced. Across the local businesses we manage, a healthy cost per lead usually lands somewhere between $20 and $75, depending on the platform and how competitive the service is. Meta ads tend to run cheaper per lead. Google search tends to run more expensive per lead but with higher intent.
Some practical rules:
If your cost per lead is under $15, celebrate quietly, then check lead quality. Very cheap leads are sometimes junk.
If it's creeping up month over month, look at your ads first. Tired creative is the usual culprit.
If it's over $150 for a routine service, something is broken: targeting, the offer, or the landing page.
Judge cost per lead next to the value of a new patient. A $100 lead is a bargain if a new patient is worth $3,000.
Booking rate: what happens after the phone rings
This is where good marketing goes to die. You can generate great leads and still have a bad month if nobody books them. A healthy booking rate, meaning leads that turn into a scheduled appointment, is usually 40 to 60 percent. Strong front desks push past that.
If you're under 30 percent, the problem is almost never the ads. It's missed calls, slow callbacks, or a front desk that's answering questions instead of offering appointments. Call speed matters enormously. A lead called back within five minutes is dramatically more likely to book than one called back the next day.
Show rate: did they actually come in?
Booked isn't the finish line. For new patients, a show rate of 75 to 85 percent is solid. Below 70 percent and you're paying for appointments that never happen. Reminder texts, a confirmation call the day before, and a short welcome message that tells people what to expect all help. We wrote a whole post on why no-shows are really a marketing problem, and it's the cheapest fix on this list.
Website conversion rate
Of the people who land on your website, how many call, fill out a form, or book? For a local practice, 3 to 8 percent is a reasonable range for overall site traffic, and dedicated landing pages for ads should do better, often 8 to 15 percent. If your site converts under 2 percent, people are showing up and leaving. Usually that means a slow site, a hidden phone number, or no clear next step on mobile.
Reviews: the quiet benchmark
Reviews don't show up on your ad dashboard, but they move every other number on this page. A good month for most local practices means four to ten new Google reviews, with your average staying at 4.7 or above. Recent reviews matter more than total count. Fifty reviews from three years ago looks worse than twenty from the last six months.
If you're getting fewer than two new reviews a month, you don't have a review problem. You have an asking problem. Build it into checkout and it fixes itself.
Google Business Profile activity
Your Google profile is often the first place people find you, before your site. Check calls, direction requests, and website clicks from the profile every month. You're not looking for a magic number here. You're looking for a steady or rising trend. A sudden drop usually means something changed: wrong hours, a suspended listing, a new competitor, or a category change you didn't make.
Putting it together: a simple monthly scorecard
You don't need a forty-page report. You need one page with these lines on it, compared to last month and the same month last year:
New patients or customers who showed up, and where they came from
Total leads, split by source
Cost per lead by platform
Booking rate
New patient show rate
Website conversion rate
New Google reviews and average rating
Ad spend and cost per new patient
That last line, cost per new patient, is the one to circle. It ties everything together. If a new patient costs you $150 to acquire and is worth $2,000 over the relationship, your marketing is working, even if one month's ads looked a little soft.
What a bad month actually tells you
Bad months happen. Holidays, weather, school breaks, and a competitor running a big promotion can all dent the numbers. One soft month is noise. Two in a row is a signal. Three is a pattern you need to act on.
When the numbers dip, walk down the funnel in order: leads, then booking rate, then show rate. The first stage that falls off is where your problem lives. That keeps you from doing the thing we see most often, which is cutting the ad budget when the real issue is that nobody's answering the phone at lunch.
Want someone to read the numbers with you?
If you're not sure whether your marketing had a good month, or you're getting reports full of impressions and clicks that don't connect to real patients, we can help. Here in Rochester and beyond, we build simple scorecards that tell owners the truth. Reach out at brummble.com or call 585-802-1377 and let's take a look.
Comments